Guest review links.
Send a demo to anyone. Get feedback on the exact bars — no account needed.
Send a version of a song to anyone — a producer, a session player, a friend with good ears. They open a link, listen, and leave comments on the exact bars of the exact track. No account, no app.
- Every track of the version shown as its own lane, playing the full mix
- Guests pick a range of bars on a track and comment on it, or leave a note on the whole song
- Guest comments land on your tracks in the mixer, in the project chat and in notifications
- Any comment or note goes to the project checklist in one click
- Expiry (7 days, 30 days or never), downloads, structure and chords are up to you; password protection on Band plans
Feedback, without the guesswork
Every band knows the loop. You send a bounce to someone whose ears you trust, and the answer comes back as a voice memo or a chat message: around 1:40 the drums feel busy
. Which drums? Which version? Was that 1:40 on the old intro? By the time you find the spot, the thought has gone cold.
Guest review links close that loop. You share one version of a song; your guest listens in the browser and points at the exact bars of the exact track. The feedback arrives in your project — on the track it’s about — where the band can answer it, argue about it and turn it into work.
Leave a comment like a guest
Nothing yet — pick some bars.
- Re-record bass in chorus 2
How it works
- 01
Share a version
In the mixer, press Share and pick the version. Decide what guests can do — comment, download WAV and MP3, see structure and chords — and when the link expires. The link captures that version as it is now; your edits afterwards don’t change what the guest hears.
- 02
They listen, track by track
The guest opens the link in any browser. No sign-up, no app. They hear the mix and see every track as its own lane, under the song’s sections, with a volume boost for quiet rooms.
- 03
They point at the bars
Press Comment, drag across the bars on the track they mean, and write. Feedback about the song as a whole goes in a note instead. Every comment carries its track, its bars and its time.
- 04
It lands where you work
Guest comments appear on your tracks in the mixer — monochrome, so you can tell them from the band’s — and in the project chat and notifications. Reply, discuss, and send anything to the checklist with one click.
It lands where the band already works
A guest comment isn’t a separate inbox to check. It is a comment on your track, drawn in monochrome so you know at a glance it came from outside the band. Notes on the whole song arrive in the project chat. The bell in the mixer collects both.
When a note is worth doing, Add to checklist copies it into the song’s checklist with its track, bar and author — so “hold the snare back” becomes a task someone can tick off.
The details we sweated
No account, no friction
The fastest feedback comes from people who don’t have to sign up for anything. A link and a name are enough.
Comments on bars, per track
A range on one track, not a vague timestamp. “Bass, bars 17–20” is something you can act on before the next rehearsal.
Notes on the whole song
Some thoughts aren’t about a bar. Whole-song notes go straight into the project chat, so the band sees them in context.
From comment to task
Add to checklist turns any comment or note into a checklist item for the song — with the track, the bar and who said it.
You stay in control
Expiry, downloads, structure and chords are per link. Revoke a link in one click; on Band plans, add a password.
Private by design
Review pages aren’t indexed, carry no third-party trackers, and guests never see the band’s internal comments.
Who it’s for
Producers
Send the rough mix to the artist and get notes on the exact bars, instead of a voice memo that says “the second chorus, kind of”.
Bands
Play the new demo to a session player, a manager or a friend with good ears — before you book the studio, not after.
Teachers & mentors
Review a student’s arrangement track by track and leave feedback they can find again next week.
Feedback on bars is the heart of sonicdesk — read more about comments on bars and how versions keep every take.
Questions
- Do guests need a sonicdesk account to leave feedback?
- No. Anyone with the link can listen and comment. They type a name once, and it’s remembered on their device for next time.
- Can guests hear each track on its own?
- Guests hear the full mix of the version you shared, and they see every audio track as its own lane — so a comment can point at the drums in bars 33–36 rather than “somewhere in the chorus”.
- Can guests see the band’s own comments?
- No. A guest only sees the comments left through their link, plus the band’s replies to them. Your internal discussion stays internal.
- What happens to the feedback when a link expires or is revoked?
- It stays with the band. Guest comments are ordinary comments on your tracks, so they remain in the project after the link stops working.
- Can I protect a review link with a password?
- Yes, on Band plans. You can also choose an expiry of 7 days, 30 days or never, and whether guests may download the audio or see the song’s structure and chords.